아이구 근데 보는데 왤케 짠하냐..ㅠㅠ 닝닝 이제 갓 스무살이고 완전 어린 신인인데 실수하고 순간 얼마나 얼고 당황했을까 같은 그룹 멤버들이랑 대선배들 앞에서 실수해버려서 그런데 진짜 당황한 티도 안내고 바로 웃으면서 다시 할 수 있다고 자연스럽게 받아치고 계속하는거 너무 대단하고 찡하다 정말 멘탈 강하고 긍정적인 것 같음.. 그리고 닝닝 계속 노래할 수 잇게 분위기 띄워준 아형 멤버들도 너무 고맙고 ㅠㅠ
@@정혜원-l6y7h 아이돌치고 유난히 어린 나이라고 할 수 없는건 맞지만 평균적인 스무살의 모습을 생각하면 어린거 맞죠..ㅠㅠ 갓 성인이고 어른 딱지는 붙었지만 겪어본 건 많이 없고, 감정적으로도 많이 불안하고 미성숙한 때이고.. 무엇보다 인생을 살아온 시간이 짧으니까 당황스러운 상황에서 현명하게 대처하기 어려울 수 있는데 닝닝은 크게 동요하지 않고 스스로를 잘 다잡아서 대단해 보였어요 ㅎㅎ
She was about to belt it but instead her voice cracked. To make the sitaution not awkward, the casts reacted by accusing her being black mamba which shifted the attention. In her 2nd try, she did great tho instead of belting she used her head voice instead.
@@papaya.00462 uhmm no there are no such thing as intentional cracks unless its a squeak like Sia's. Again, not against Aespa but sharing only the truth. If it was part of the script as a concept of the game, so all of them would intentionally crack their voices or maybe ruin their singing just to ACT like the black mamba? Again, she did justice in her skills as she tried again.
It's a bit like a pro athlete trying to mess something up on purpose like kicking a ball off target or missing a pitch in batting practice. Muscle memory and instinct fight them subconsciously. I imagine it is the same for trained singers. Trying to consciously mess up a note requires them to focus on doing it and even then their vocal chords might not cooperate.
@@kentvesser9484 I agree! I just wanted to point that part out as well. I am also an athlete (although not a pro 🥲) but fighting against muscle memory when learning new skills or messing things up on purpose really is harder to do than doing the skill itself. Thank you for the explanation!! ❤️🔥
So basically in this episode, they are trying to find a black mamba, the villain throughout the whole segments. When her voice crack, their script goes “Is Ning the black mamba?” “Pls don’t be the BM” and etc. And the second time she sang it without issues, they all relieved that she ain’t the black mamba. Other segments also got the MC purposely cracking the recorder sounds and etc.
@@오늉-f6f 아마 에스파 포지션이 아직 공식적으로 정해져 있지 않은 것 같아요 (저도 잘 몰라요). 하지만 지금 에스파 보면 많은 사람은 닝닝이 에스파의 메인보컬이라고 인정했어요. 닝닝은 목소리도 좋고 노래 파트도 많고 데뷔 곡 블랙맘바 고음도 담당했었어요. 그래서 인지... 혹시 제가 어딘가에 틀렸다면 당신이 그냥 제가 스스로 닝닝한테 칭찬하는 걸 보시면 돼요.
she really is phenomenal. When she participated in that singing show in China at the age of TWELVE. Just goosebumps all over. How can a child that young have such a clear and powerful voice and be filled with so much emotion? She's definitely was a child prodigy.
So true. Her voice is so distinct and idk flavourful. I am a 3rd gen girlgroup stan but lilyM and ningning are two best 4th gen singers in my opinion. They are so refreshing to listen to.
Even if it wasn't its fine every singer has cracked at least one, is normal when your are singing live. Laugh it off its really the only positive way to come out of this
@@bluequeen8022 yes it is normal, even Taeyeon and Solar's (best girl vocalists of all time) voice cracks. But in Ningning's situation it is obviously planned. I do it all the time to play with my voice and there is a really distinct sound when you're faking a crack versus a natural voice crack. 😂
Yea and you really see that in Ning's face the moment after she tried to crack the hight note a little that she did this on purpose. Also look at Karina she was expecting it. She knows her voice range very well and knows when to switch the octave in the right and in the worst moment. And she did this in the worst moment on purpose. Very simple.
Unpopular opinion but i really want ateez jongho and ningning to collab for a high range song , they both are litterally the king and queen of high range in 4th generation
ningning’s technique is insane. at this point coming for her vocals despite the group having only 3 songs is like asking for a public humiliation so don’t even try.
but didn't she train for years before debuting ? Im not saying that she should automatically be the best singer of the world after debuting but it's not either like she never sang before the group's 3 first songs
@T C Wendy is great and is already well known as a great singer, Ning Ning will join her there but you don't surpass legends, Wendy, and Taeyeon are both legends now
@T Cwell thats a stupid question.. its only because of these kind of questions that hate for both ningning and wendy starts. its like instigators for the toxic people in both fandoms. please stop pitting artists against each other. And ningning is an 18 year old who just started her career because she loves to sing. and she probably loves and respects wendy too. there is no need to surpass anyone
@@emlizada9328 what's the fun if both voices sounded the same. Ningning got her own colour and uniqueness to her voice and she slayed this performance. Even if an artist try to sing like the original they wouldn't be able to wipe out the original uniqueness of kim ah joong's voice.
I must say that: when she cracked at first that she acted according to the script, she can sing easily like then so don't doubt about her talent. SHE DESERVES OUR RECOGNITION
ya, it was pretty obvious it was intentional... just look at her face when she cracked.. the second time she was very relaxed. It was harder to crack her voice than to sing it properly
Too obvious . As her second attempt was done without effort. Too easy. Means It was way still in her octave range. It was too strange if the first attempt she was slipped as if it's too high. The slip on the first trial would be understandbale only if the 2nd attempt shows that she needs to sing with effort (that it were a high note for her; which she showed the opposite, she sung it easily, means her high notes range is still way above that)
And see karina's reactiin at 00:31 . Just before ningning was slipped, for a second karina seemed like waiting/expecting something. And after ningning slipped, karina nodding her head. A leader like karina's character, would have been worried or concerned when her member is doing a mistake, as she did in other aespa appearsnce on other show.
@@감나무-j9m 가수도 본인만의 음역대가 있을 거 아니에요.. 고음 잘하면 노래 잘하는 게 아니라 그 음역대에서 잘 부르는 게 잘 부르는 거예요 ㅋㅋ 물론 고음을 잘할 수록 노래 분위기도 살고 노래에 더 유리하겠지만 고음 잘한다고 노래 잘하는 건 아님ㅇㅇ 닝닝이 부른 마리아는 웬만한 가수들도 못부르는데 저 정도면 개 잘하는 거지.. 심지어 데뷔 1년도 안 됐고 예능 초보인 거 고려해 보면 진짜 ㅎㄷㄷ한 거임
@@감나무-j9m 예능 초보고 저 곡이 마냥 쉬운 건 아니잖아.. 음정 흔들려도 저 정도면 잘 부르는데 억지로 트집 좀 잡지 마셈ㅋㅋㄱ 데뷔 1년도 안 되면 저런 예능 경험이 거의 없기에 긴장 엄청했을 거임 ;; 아~ 그리고 너 첫번 째 다답글 보니까 닝닝은 가수니까 저 정도하는 게 당연하다했더라? 그럼 못부르는 건 아니란 건데 나한텐 음정 겁나 흔들린다고 싸잡아대넹ㅋㅋㅋ
It was really funny. I guess she was too nervous. I’m sure she can hit that cleanly if she was less nervous. Also, I love how she changed her tactic to hit that hight note. Effortless and so clean.
Actually it was scripted, ningning did the crack on purpose that's how they play the game and also knowing bros always prepared everything in order for a show
she's holding back herself and she haven't shown her fullest potential bc she wants us to anticipate more in the future. this is just a teaser of what she can do more. we all know sm main vocalists never fails us to give the best among the best. and ningning is just 18?!?! she can show us more in the future, just wait.
![[Knowing Bros] aespa - HIT SONG DANCE MEDLEY🔥 (including DRAMA)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/zFkvb95hQDk/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Pre-release] LISA's upgraded Thai dance⚡️= 'Crab dance'♪ (point. poker face😶) Knowing bros EP.251](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/01iz9kmvbxg/mqdefault.jpg)
![[4K] aespa NINGNING - “Something Like That” Band LIVE Concert [it's Live] K-POP live music show](/img/1.gif)
내가 저상황이면 머쓱하고 웃겨서 맠ㅎ리아앜ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ으흐흨ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ아핰ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ이러면서 제대로 못했을텐데 다시 잘하네 닝닝이는 블랙맘바가 아니다!!!!
존나웃기네ㅋㅋ
디즈니송에 찰떡일거같은 음색임 슴이 좋아하는 정석의 보컬느낌이랄까 ㅎ 닝닝이 앞으로도 화이팅
she looks like badaaaa
@@JanJan13 아 ㄹㅇㅋㅋ
헐 진짜다 ㅠ ㅇㅈ
ㄹㅇ 정석 보컬 느낌
미친미친미틴ㅠㅠ
진짜
음색이
바다같다... 이름도 닝닝이야 ㅠㅠ 너무 귀엽...
이름이 너무 귀여워요 닝닝ㅎㅎㅋㅋㅋ
별명이 아가바다래요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ개귀엽...
아기바다 닝닝 ㅠㅠㅠ 별명이 너무 이뻐유 아기바다
웃을때 약간 조이같은데 노래 부르면 바다가 되네
오 바다 ㅇㅈ
0:30 에서는 마리“아” 에서 무리하게 성구전환을 시도하다 성대 접지가 불안정해 음이탈이 발생했는데 빠르게 깨닫고
2:50 에서는 마“리” 에서 미리 성구전환을 해서 안정적이고 티안나게 고음까지 믹스로 연결했네요!
엄청나게 노력하신게 보이는 보컬입니다…리스펙!
와 목소리 바꾸는 걸 성구전환이라고 하구나...! 마리에서 바뀌었다고 생각했는데 신기하네요 !!!
@@fististzo 저렇게 가성느낌 없이 믹스보이스를 내는게 엄청난 훈련이 필요하더라구요 ㅠ
오 정확하게 짚어내시네요 굳굳
걍 쎈가성으로 낸 거 아닌가??.
@@yoon7838 보컬은 점점 가성과 진성의 경계가 모호해지는 믹스지점을 훈련합니다!
예능 초보라서 긴장 되게 많이 했을거고 실수한 순간 오만가지 생각 다났을텐데 저 예능 베테랑들 상황 재밌게 풀어나가는거보소... 비록 실수 했지만 조금은 마음 편했을듯! 진짜 다들 멋있다
아형 멤버들이 진짜 다 노련함 창피하지 않게 장난쳐주는게 ㄹㅇ
ㅇㅇ
컨셉이라는데?
아는형님 실수해도 되게 예능으로 넘어가게 해 주는 거 진짜 좋다.... 두 번 부를 때 다같이 뛰어 주는 거 보기좋음
저거 실수가 아니라 대본일걸요 ㅋㅋ 닝닝이도 의심컷 하나는 나와야 하니깐
@@검마잡자 대본 맞는거 같은게.... 닝닝이가 음이탈이 나도 카리나 표정이 너무 평온해요
@@성이름-c5j6q 헉 저도 같은 포인트에 얘기하려 그랬어요 역시 선생님은 배우신분~ 💕
대본은 절대 아닌거같은데..ㅋㅋ 그냥 긴장으로 인한 실수를 재밌게 풀어나간거뿐 연기는 아닌거같음
저런 음이탈을 맘대로 컨트롤할 수 있다고?ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ능력자네 닝닝
긴장 많이했을텐데 재도전해서 씩씩하게 성공하는 거도 보기 좋고 실수로 예능 분량 챙긴거도 좋고 닝닝 윈윈했어
닝닝윈윈 너무 귀엽네요...
닝닝윈윈ㅋㅋㅋ
저건 대본이죠 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@hhhnnn2827 뭔 대본이야...ㅋㅋㅋ 저런 삑사리를 일부러 낼 수 있냐 대본을 쓴다면 저런 대본을 왜 쓰겠냐 그냥 긴장한 신인의 자연스럽고 인간적인 실수여서 귀엽게 좋게 보이는거지
ㅋㅋ 오우 너무 순진하고 그렇죠 믿음이 중요하죠 ㅋㅋ
초반에 긴장해서 힘도 많이 들어가고 평소 부르던대로 못부르는듯 뒤에 부른건 ㄹㅇ 바다같고 너무 좋다….욕하는 사람들 맨날 에스파 노래 못한다고 수근수근대던데 이 영상 더 떴으면 좋겠음
스엠 특유의 깨끗하고 맑은 창법 너무 좋음 ㅋㅋ
다시 도전해서 성공하는것도 쉬운게 아닌데 목소리 좋다 진짜 실력인증
아이구 근데 보는데 왤케 짠하냐..ㅠㅠ 닝닝 이제 갓 스무살이고 완전 어린 신인인데 실수하고 순간 얼마나 얼고 당황했을까 같은 그룹 멤버들이랑 대선배들 앞에서 실수해버려서 그런데 진짜 당황한 티도 안내고 바로 웃으면서 다시 할 수 있다고 자연스럽게 받아치고 계속하는거 너무 대단하고 찡하다 정말 멘탈 강하고 긍정적인 것 같음.. 그리고 닝닝 계속 노래할 수 잇게 분위기 띄워준 아형 멤버들도 너무 고맙고 ㅠㅠ
@@정혜원-l6y7h 선미님이랑 소희님이 엄청 어린 나이에 데뷔한거지 닝닝이 어리지 않은건 아니죠...
@@정혜원-l6y7h 아니...20살이면 어린거지... 요즘 아이돌 데뷔 나이 허들이 낮아져서 그럼...ㅜ 주변에 20살보면 재수하는 경우도 있는데 이런거 보면 진짜 개어린거임
@@정혜원-l6y7h 아이돌치고 유난히 어린 나이라고 할 수 없는건 맞지만 평균적인 스무살의 모습을 생각하면 어린거 맞죠..ㅠㅠ 갓 성인이고 어른 딱지는 붙었지만 겪어본 건 많이 없고, 감정적으로도 많이 불안하고 미성숙한 때이고.. 무엇보다 인생을 살아온 시간이 짧으니까 당황스러운 상황에서 현명하게 대처하기 어려울 수 있는데 닝닝은 크게 동요하지 않고 스스로를 잘 다잡아서 대단해 보였어요 ㅎㅎ
@@dhhdhdhdjkkdmfmm 아이돌들 나이가 점점 어려지는 건 아님..옛날부터 막내들은 15.16때 데뷔하는 애들 많았고 소녀시대도 전원 미자일 때 데뷔함
그냥 우리가 나이 들어가서 점점 어려진다고 느끼는거ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅠㅠ
@@dddd-x6f3d 맞음
근데 요즘 10대들은 그걸 모를듯
그냥 어릴 때 데뷔한 사람 하면 장원영?
닝닝은 진짜 sm에서 데뷔를 안할수없었겠네. 얼굴 진짜 예쁜데 음색도 좋고 고음잘하고 보컬탄탄한 딱 그룹에서 필요한 멤버.
그냥 중국돈이 필요한거지
얼굴이요? ㅋㅋ
얼굴도 이뻐요
@@잭-p4s 얼굴로 까는 게 젤 웃김 ㅋㅋ
@@잭-p4s닝닝이 안예쁘다고?ㅋㅋ
와 근데 고음 올라가는거 진짜 깔끔하네
매력은 진짜 닝닝이가 탑급인듯 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 말투도 그렇고 평소 하는 행동이나 말들이 너무 귀엽다 노래도 잘하고 ... 나중에 애니메이션 같은거 OST 불러도 괜찮을듯
@@cheersmate_진짜요?? 뭔지 알려주세요 ㅜ🙏
@@계옮-h9s 샤이닝스타입니다
그게 뭔지까지는 기억이 잘 안나지만
샤이닝스타가 에셈이랑 협업 해서 제작한거라
에셈 노래들이 많이 나왔는데
제 기억으론 닝닝도 에셈노래중에 몇개를 부른걸로 기억하고 있어요
@@윈터의겨울에 앗 감사합니당
닝닝 너무 좋아 💖
노래할때 목소리가 조금 허스키 해지는게 매력적...
2:50 뒤에 마리아는 너무 좋음. 바다 수평선 너머에 누군가를 위해 부르는 느낌
@@귀요미-r2g2s 저두요
대박 어떻게 그런 생각을 하세요ㅠ
근데 마리아할때 미세하게 떠는거 어떻게 한건가요?
@@Mubulbam 네네
ㄹㅇ피치피치핏치 인어들이 이런노래 불렀을것같음 ㅜㅜㅜ
근데 스엠은 보컬교육? 발음교육을 어떻게 시키길래 외국멤들이 한국어로 노래를 저래 잘부르냐...내 발음보다 더 또박또박함 ㅋㅋ
닝닝 외국인이었어요....? 처음 알았다
@@banbann77 yes Yi Zhou is chinese (:
외국이 아니라 중국 아님?
@@이름추천부탁 중국이 외국이 아님 뭐임
@@Siuuuchoi 중국은 나라가아니라 그냥 쓰레기라는 소리인것같은데.
와 어떻게 이렇게 쉽게 부르냨ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 대박 가창력 쩐다 ㅠㅠ
블랙맘바 포장은 ㄹㅇ 예능천재 아니십니까... 진짜 저거 무조건 분위기 싸해지는 포인트인데 저걸 저렇게 잡으시네... 예능인 순간대처능력은 진짜 인정해야함...
닝닝이 안 민망하게 잘 대처한듯ㅋㅋㅋ
읭 에스파 편 자체 컨셉이 블랙맘바 찾는 거임••• 그래서 멤버들 잘하는 거 시키고 못하면 블랙맘바야~ 하고 이미 들어간 상황인데 거기에 닝닝이가 삑사리내서 블맘이냐고 한거구
@@lIlIlIlIlI_lI 그래도 다른 쪽으로 넘어갈 수도 있었는데 최대한 민망하지 않게 실수할 친구가 아니라며 장난친 게 센스있다는거 아닐까요??
@@shiningfaceicantseeit 블랙맘바 포장이래자나요 블맘 대사는 이미 잇는 컨셉인데 그거 가지고 칭찬하니 하는 소리잖아
@@lIlIlIlIlI_lI 아 잘못된 표현이네 원래 블랙맘바 찾는 건데 블랙맘바 포장이란 걸 못 봤어요 ㅠ
내가 저상황이면 얼굴 그냥 토마토 됨 ㄹㅇ.....
많이 당황하지 않고 다시하는거 너무 대단해....
나 솔직히 대본인줄 .. ...
본인을 빗대어서 프로가수와 일반인의 차이를 말하고 싶은건가
칭찬하는건 좋은데 본인 비하는 왜함ㅋ
@@김윤주-h8k 걍 그렇다는 거 아님?ㅋㅋ 나도 가창 시험 볼 때 존나 떨리는데ㅋㅋ
닝닝은 머리가 토마토 됨
The fact that she struggled more with making her voice crack then her actually singing the high note just shows the talent this girl holds!!!
bro she literally didn’t hit the note
@@simpforwooyong3375 ok u hit the note then
She was about to belt it but instead her voice cracked. To make the sitaution not awkward, the casts reacted by accusing her being black mamba which shifted the attention. In her 2nd try, she did great tho instead of belting she used her head voice instead.
@@stanloonajuststanloona9273 actually her cracking the voice was a part of the script…
Edit: n girl ur right STAN LOONA!!!
@@papaya.00462 uhmm no there are no such thing as intentional cracks unless its a squeak like Sia's. Again, not against Aespa but sharing only the truth. If it was part of the script as a concept of the game, so all of them would intentionally crack their voices or maybe ruin their singing just to ACT like the black mamba? Again, she did justice in her skills as she tried again.
A real cutie. Didn't back down. A strong woman at such a young age.
Respect.
bada x ningning mariaaaa
the fact that she faked a voice crack proves she's confident. i love her
@@pinkinmybloodd yesssss ning give me the same vibe oh my goshhhhh ning voice is so so so powerful
😂😂
They were playing a game she faked the crack
첨에 진성 쌩목으로 지르려다가 목소리 갈라지니까 가성 섞어서 깔끔하게 불럿네. 이 노래는 진성이 맛깔지지만 닝닝 가성이 넘 예쁜듯
진성도 들어보고 싶다 예능에서 부르려고 한거보면 원래는 잘 했을 것 같은데ㅠㅠ 너무 아쉽
긴장되서 ㅠㅠㅠ
믹스보이스임 처음에 진성쪽으로 더 가려다가 숨더 섞어서 가성쪽으로 더 움직인건 맞음 진성이다 가성이다라는 기준자체가 모호해서 표현이 그럴 수 있는데 이해만 된다면야..
반가성에서 쫌더 진성에 가까운듯!!!
처음거듣고 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ귀여워죽는줄..
닝닝 님이 삑사리 때문에 많이 당황하셨을텐데 다시 한번 부르게 해주는 거 진짜 좋다
ㅇㅈ
근데 닝닝님이 일부러 삑사리 낸거 아니었어요?
@@안냐세여땃쥐입니다길 표정으로 봐서 엄청 당황한 거 보아 제 생각으론 일부러 한 건 아닌 것 같아요 또 일부러 했다고 해도 자기 이미지만 나빠질 텐데 굳이..
일부러 하는거임 멤버들 표정 보면 알게됨. 멤버들 당황하지 않은 표정.
@@crystalkarbia2024 근데 일부러 할 이유가 없지않나?
Why does it look like she had a harder time intentionally cracking her voice than actually hitting the note 😭WHAT A QUEEN
It's a bit like a pro athlete trying to mess something up on purpose like kicking a ball off target or missing a pitch in batting practice. Muscle memory and instinct fight them subconsciously. I imagine it is the same for trained singers. Trying to consciously mess up a note requires them to focus on doing it and even then their vocal chords might not cooperate.
@@kentvesser9484 I agree! I just wanted to point that part out as well. I am also an athlete (although not a pro 🥲) but fighting against muscle memory when learning new skills or messing things up on purpose really is harder to do than doing the skill itself. Thank you for the explanation!! ❤️🔥
Wait she intentionally cracked her voice?? NAURRRR
@@lucvadeboncoeur358 yesss she did it😂😂
@@reveee.127 Hmmm?? Why does she look so embarassed after her voice cracked?
The best part is when Giselle, Karina and Winter rejoiced in happiness because Ningning hit all the notes perfectly!
seeing them pause during the high note and jumping afterwards 😂😂😂😂
proud unnies
She is their baby
Ikr they're sooo cute hahaha
So basically in this episode, they are trying to find a black mamba, the villain throughout the whole segments. When her voice crack, their script goes “Is Ning the black mamba?” “Pls don’t be the BM” and etc. And the second time she sang it without issues, they all relieved that she ain’t the black mamba.
Other segments also got the MC purposely cracking the recorder sounds and etc.
음색과 창법이 바다 닮았다.
끝음처리나 발음 다듬으면 제2의 바다/제1의 닝닝이가 될 수 있을 거 같다.
헉 듣자마자 바다 생각했는데
생긴덕도약간닮음!
제 1의 닝닝 가자!!!! 울 닝닝😍🥰
@@황윤주-e3w 웃을 때 느낌이 확 남 뭔가 되게 시원하고 호탕하게 생긴...? ㅋㅋ
목소리까지 확신의 스엠상..
삑사리 나도 당황하지 않고 끝까지 고음 지르시는거 프로...
@N̶a̶r̶g̶i̶s̶𓅓 Kim Ah Joong - Maria
하 ㅠㅠ 멋있어 닝닝❤️
나락!
@@라이언-p1l 니 얼굴
맞네 삑 났는데도 일단 끝까지 끄네 대단하다
아니 근데 삑소리 난거 순수하게 그냥 웃긴데 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅇㅇ 그냥 진짜 귀엽다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
가수맞음?
@@hyeonsu-hl2ff 닌 인간 맞음?
@@모택동말 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ개웃겨
ㅇㅈㅋㅋㅋㅋ
음색 너무 이쁘다...다들 조마조마하면서 응원해주는 거 졸귀ㅋㅋㅋ큐ㅠㅠ
SHE'S THE MAIN VOCALIST FOR A REASON! YEEES, NING YIZHUO EVERYONE!
Wait is that her real name 😭 i don't know it 😭
@@andikarafael8675 Yes
@@andikarafael8675 her english name is ning vivian
@@ladynoir5990 what a cool name 😭
PERIODTTT
NING'S VOCALS ARE NO JOKE. I'M SO PROUD OF HER.
Hmmm
Not only top vocal skill. She has a variety skill , Ningning deserve everything.
Yes
삑사리도 당당하게 내는 최강창민느낌ㄱㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ졸귀여
댓이 없넹
2:45 뒤에서 언니들 손 꼭 잡고 우리 막냉이 잘해라...! 같이 긴장하는 거 너무 귀엽고 이쁘다ㅠㅠ
닝이 근데 진짜 노래부를 때 한국어 발음 되게 정확함…
와 마리아 완곡하는거 듣고 싶다 너무 시원해
올려올려 댓올려
ningning faking a voice crack just shows how confident she is with her vocals
Sorry but why did she fake a voice crack?
@@elleguevarra7948 it's the concept of this episode. They are trying to find the black mamba
@@elleguevarra7948 since they're trying to 'find' the black mamba, so it was to create suspicion, and for entertainment purpose obv
@@elleguevarra7948 Black Mamba game
@@pinkgangsta6157 mbaaak, spertinya kita berjodoh 😭🤣
목소리가 디즈니ost 진짜 잘 어울릴 듯ㅜㅠㅠ
존버요
Aespa didn't even look shocked when Ningning cracked her voice. So, they probably know what was about to happen.
대박이다... 닝닝이 중국인인데 한국어 잘 하네,, 원래 외국인이 보통 그룹의 댄서나 랩 담당하는데 닝닝이 애스파의 메인보컬이었구나 한국어 잘 불러어
"에스파"고요
에스파에는 포지션이 정해져 있지않아요
@@오늉-f6f 아마 에스파 포지션이 아직 공식적으로 정해져 있지 않은 것 같아요 (저도 잘 몰라요). 하지만 지금 에스파 보면 많은 사람은 닝닝이 에스파의 메인보컬이라고 인정했어요. 닝닝은 목소리도 좋고 노래 파트도 많고 데뷔 곡 블랙맘바 고음도 담당했었어요. 그래서 인지... 혹시 제가 어딘가에 틀렸다면 당신이 그냥 제가 스스로 닝닝한테 칭찬하는 걸 보시면 돼요.
마음이님 제 중국어 선생님이랑 말투 비슷하시네여 ㅎㅎ 예쁜 말투
@@hanaflxd1083 제가 봤던 영상에서는 포시션이 정해져있지 않다고 해서 전 그렇게 알고 있었는데 찾아보니까 정해져 있더라구요. 닝닝이가 메인보컬이 맞는거같아요
@@오늉-f6f 그럼 사과 하셔야죠
At this point,we could finally tell she's the vocalist queen of her generation. She's too good at her age.Ningning never disappoints.
she really is phenomenal. When she participated in that singing show in China at the age of TWELVE. Just goosebumps all over. How can a child that young have such a clear and powerful voice and be filled with so much emotion? She's definitely was a child prodigy.
I agree with both ningning never disappoint btw my name is brook or Brooklyn and I am girl
NING NING TOP MAIN VOCALIST OF THIS GENERATION
Swan and Chowon are on another level.
@@iz-dle4856 You are delusional.
I love ningning's voice so much. it's so refreshing and reminds me of disney soundtracks. I hope sm pays more attention to her.
Yeah
So true. Her voice is so distinct and idk flavourful. I am a 3rd gen girlgroup stan but lilyM and ningning are two best 4th gen singers in my opinion. They are so refreshing to listen to.
Same feeling! She has a Disney voice
Ningning's mistake was in the script guys, she need to make mistake so others will say that she is black mamba. That's why she did that
Even if it wasn't its fine every singer has cracked at least one, is normal when your are singing live. Laugh it off its really the only positive way to come out of this
@@bluequeen8022 yes it is normal, even Taeyeon and Solar's (best girl vocalists of all time) voice cracks. But in Ningning's situation it is obviously planned. I do it all the time to play with my voice and there is a really distinct sound when you're faking a crack versus a natural voice crack. 😂
@@bluequeen8022 if it wasn't then they will cut it. it so obviously scripted kkk
Yea and you really see that in Ning's face the moment after she tried to crack the hight note a little that she did this on purpose. Also look at Karina she was expecting it. She knows her voice range very well and knows when to switch the octave in the right and in the worst moment. And she did this in the worst moment on purpose. Very simple.
진짜 이건 닝닝이가 수년간 연생하면서 노력한 모습이 드러난 클립이네.. 아무래도 예능초보라 첨에 긴장하고 목에 힘이 많이 들가면서 삑사리난건데, ㄹㅇ 프로인게 바로 힘빼서 고음 사뿐하게 올렸잖슴ㅋㅋ 웬만한 자신감 아니면 저렇게 다시 바로잡는거 절대 안된다
내가 봤을땐 이 노래에대한 이해도가 없어서 그런듯
쉽게 소리 나올것 같아서 막 불렀는데 생각보다 음정이 높고 성량이 쌘부분이라서 컨트롤 미스 난거고
두번째떄는 안정적이게 부른거고
@@이멍뭉-o2v 다 미리 자신있는 노래 정하고 연습해서 오는 걸 텐데 막 선정한 건 아닐테고 그냥 긴장해서 삑사리 난 거겠죠
그냥 진성으로 도전했다가 안되니까 두번째에는 안전하게 가성으로 가는거구만 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 무슨 프로 ㅇㅈㄹ ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@user-iv4mr1zp1t ㄹㅇ ㅋㅋ
@@user-iv4mr1zp1t 프로정신을 칭찬한거 아님?
실수할까봐 다들 일동얼음하는거 개웃겨ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㄱㅋㅋㄱㅋㅋㅋㅋㄱㄱㅋㅋㅋㅋㄲㅋㅋㅋ 얼마나 긴장됐을까ㅜㅜ 저기분 진짜 넘 이해됨..ㅜㅜ
닝이 원래 잘하는 거 아니까 블랙맘바로 재밋게 풀어주는 거 너무 보기좋다
와 음색 뭐야 노래 잘하는건 알고있었지만 진짜 너무잘한다
2:51 닝닝이 성공해서 뒤에 멤버들 뛰는 거 왜 이렇게 귀엽냐ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@N̶a̶r̶g̶i̶s̶𓅓 Ave Maria by Kim ah joong
ningning is proving that she is 4th gen vocal queen. She is leading YASS!!
Unpopular opinion but i really want ateez jongho and ningning to collab for a high range song , they both are litterally the king and queen of high range in 4th generation
@@fixon919 this would be fire 😩
@@fixon919 yes!!!
Well before nmixx she is
@@chuunevis4560 nope didn't understand
와 근데 음색도 좋고 뭔가 보컬스킬?기교라 해야되나
되게 자연스럽게 이어지고 노래 잘부른다
닝닝이 원래 잘하는애인걸 아니까 우리도 웃는거지 귀여워ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
she has really stable voice omfg main vocalist for a reason
ningning’s technique is insane. at this point coming for her vocals despite the group having only 3 songs is like asking for a public humiliation so don’t even try.
but didn't she train for years before debuting ? Im not saying that she should automatically be the best singer of the world after debuting but it's not either like she never sang before the group's 3 first songs
@@Sissi-wn6cw Yeah, she was introduced as SMRookie in 2016
@T C Wendy is great and is already well known as a great singer, Ning Ning will join her there but you don't surpass legends, Wendy, and Taeyeon are both legends now
@T C She'll join Wendy's level idk about passing her
@T Cwell thats a stupid question.. its only because of these kind of questions that hate for both ningning and wendy starts. its like instigators for the toxic people in both fandoms. please stop pitting artists against each other. And ningning is an 18 year old who just started her career because she loves to sing. and she probably loves and respects wendy too. there is no need to surpass anyone
저렇게 웃지만 대선배들 앞에서 실수하니까 얼마나 민망햇을까 ㅋㅋ...
ningning “ave maria” is really addicted. She is indeed a main vocalist
ave maria*
I dont see something special. Her voice is not that high compared to the original.
@@emlizada9328 what's the fun if both voices sounded the same. Ningning got her own colour and uniqueness to her voice and she slayed this performance. Even if an artist try to sing like the original they wouldn't be able to wipe out the original uniqueness of kim ah joong's voice.
I'm addicted
@@emlizada9328 it's obvious she can go highe,r like bruh she look so chill while singing it. I want to see her veins popping off.
아 미치겠다 개기엽넼ㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ진짜귀여움 ㅜㅜ
마지막에 부인하는게 킬포임 ㅋㅋ
귀여버 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
와 근데 스엠 보컬 뭐가 있나
바다가 부른 마리아랑 느낌 진짜 비슷해
오..진짜 바다랑 비슷하네요....목소리랑 스타일 전부다..
바다가 누구에요??
@@user-tpdms ses
@@user-tpdms 와.. 이제 바다를 모르는 세대가 왔구나..
와 바다를 몰라......!? 오...대박..
에스파 팬은 아닌데 진심 이틀에 한번꼴로 들으러 옴ㅠㅠ시원시원하게 올라가는게 좋고 노래 부를때 행복해 보여서 나도 행복해 지는 것 같음...너무 좋당
긴장해서 힘이 들어갔나보다..ㅠ 잘했어 닝닝이
아니 신인인데 실수하고도 다시 불러서 완벽하게 하네 와 역시 닝닝 대단쓰 언니 사랑해
ningning is really talented she has really special voice im obsessed
와 음색 개좋다...
와 목소리 진짜 깨끗하다.. 미세먼지 하나도 안마신 그런 비유보다 엄청 깨끗한 얼음 같음🧊 동글동글한 얼음이 빙하를 타고 미끄러지는 목소리🙊💞
표현이 너무 사랑스러우세용🥰
윈터도 살짝 그런 느낌이죠?? 잘 몰라서 그런데 이런 맑은 음색 좋아해!!
미세먼지 원산국 출신한테 말같지도 않은 표현이네요
@@KJ-bd2ku 그르니까요 어떻게 거기서 이런 목소리가 나와쓰까
그리구 왜 본인이 짜증나는 걸 남한테 푸세용? 예의바른 의사표현 방법 잘 모르시나봐욤
@@KJ-bd2ku 닝닝 자의로 그 나라에서 태어난건 아니잖아요 ㅠ 그나란 저도 싫어요
목소리 너무 이쁨 ㅠㅠ특유의 창법 잘 살려주면 나중에 솔로로도 대박일듯
we can't deny the fact that ningning is bada's daughter
I love both 😌🥰💟
I AGREE. HAHAHAH I LOVE THEM BOTH 💚💚💚💗💗💗
Technically she's better than bada .
@@Caspian_Xx nope..
@@Caspian_Xx they're both amazing 💖
Im deceased at how she's actually struggling at faking her crack voice while hitting that note as easy as ABC.
the fact that she agreed to the script just show how confident this girl is. She could’ve receive backlash from the “crack” but still played with it
0:30 karina was like....is she gonna follow it? Ok she did...😂
Lol did they show you the script???
@@hannahfairuz3142 Lol even this is scripted or not she slayed the song on her second time 🤷🏻♀️
@@hannahfairuz3142 yeah is the concept of the game
@@hannahfairuz3142 tanqa
아진짜 귀엽닼ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅇ너무 귀여워 다른 분들이 민망하지않게 재치있게 풀어내는 것도 웃기고 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 이것도 신인때나 볼 수 있는 거겠지ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ결론 존 나 귀 여 워
팬 아닌데 진심 매일 보러 온다... 너무 시원하고 깔끔하게 잘부름.
닝닝은 인간이라는 것이 밝혀졌습니다. 처음엔 인어인줄 알았어요...하하하 너무 예뻐요 닝닝❤️.멋져요.❤❤❤❤😂😂😂😂
she’s aespa’s main vocalist for a reason.
Yes 😌
Fr i hope people will see why and don’t question her position now
they said they don't have fixed positions recently
Yellow but she debuted as a main vocalist.
진짜 들으면 들을 수록 바다 목소리랑 비슷한 것 같음
헐 지금 바다 목소리 닮았다~~ 하면서 보고 있었는데 나만 느낀게 아니었네요!!
전혀 아닌데
데뷔티저영상부터 바다 목소리랑 비슷했응
비슷하네
오 외모도 약간비슷한거같아요
얼마나 떨렸을까.. 닝이 목소리 진짜좋다
저것도 라이브인데...두번짼 잘했잖아
I must say that: when she cracked at first that she acted according to the script, she can sing easily like then so don't doubt about her talent. SHE DESERVES OUR RECOGNITION
ya, it was pretty obvious it was intentional... just look at her face when she cracked.. the second time she was very relaxed. It was harder to crack her voice than to sing it properly
Wait.. It was scripted?
Too obvious . As her second attempt was done without effort. Too easy. Means It was way still in her octave range. It was too strange if the first attempt she was slipped as if it's too high.
The slip on the first trial would be understandbale only if the 2nd attempt shows that she needs to sing with effort (that it were a high note for her; which she showed the opposite, she sung it easily, means her high notes range is still way above that)
And see karina's reactiin at 00:31 . Just before ningning was slipped, for a second karina seemed like waiting/expecting something. And after ningning slipped, karina nodding her head.
A leader like karina's character, would have been worried or concerned when her member is doing a mistake, as she did in other aespa appearsnce on other show.
@@anonymiously5665 right, if it's not scripted karina's face won't be like that
진짜 시원함
닝닝은 엄청 슬픈노래도 상쾌한 여름노래로 만들수있을거같음
why does it look like she exerted more effort in cracking her voice than actually reaching the high note lol
Right lol because obviously fake cracking voice require effort and for her reaching high notes is nothing what a technical queen !
the crack voice is scripted
@@Courtney-ls9sv that's the point of the comment
@@stephaniemartinez3066 it was ACTUALLY scripted😅
Lol u got the point 😂
이게 뭐라고 1일 1영상 하고 있음… 닝닝 음색 너무 좋음 ㅠ
She sound like she has auto tune but she DOSENT she’s UNBELIEVABLE
Her voice is so clear that I doubt my own ears
I know right? Her voice is so light yet her range is so high it's INSANE
it has auto tune but her voice is really good idk why they still put auto tune on it
@@czarenacueto9840 No it doesn't have an auto tune,you just can't accept the fact that ningning can sing ave maria
@@kristinemkwon lmao, is not auto tune but it has something going on in the mic, it's ok tho.
*NING NING 4TH GEN MAIN VOCALIST PERIODDDTTT.*
YASSS
İT'S TRUEEEE
YASHHH
YASHHHHHH
LOUDER
her “mistake” was on purpose to find the black mamba. the concept is they show their talent to prove they’re not black mamba
right
@@allinks5262 anyone can see that its intentional too they would’ve cut it out if it wasnt 😂
Fr hahaha
Stream the entire show. I thought she is black mambaa
hajsjs
닝닝이 고음 목소리 너무좋다. ❤️
스엠이라서 그런가 김아중보다 바다가 부르는 마리아 같음
더 좋은 칭찬같음
the voice crack wasn't a mistake, it was scripted to ruin the game. incase anyone's wondering.
Ikr!!
Ppfftt..
is this a fact though? because even great singers can easily crack at times
@@ChronicKPOP They were playing a game where one of them were secretly sabotaging their performance as the “black mamba”
@@박세라-h2y ahhh. I somehow missed that - probably a language thing. It does make much more sense now... .SM's singing queen cracking... yea right 😁
Ningning is a powerhouse. SM vocal for sure. She has so much potential in variety shows and can liven up the atmosphere. She nailed it in the end!
First reply :)
Second reply!
삑사리좀날수있지 노래하다보면 우리나란 실수에 너무민감해 ㅋㅋㅋ
The black mamba got into her vocal chords in the first half😭😭😭
@Jin. yesssss so agree
@Jin. you don't seem to get what actually happened. It's a game. She did it on purpose
@@bintuae1 i think he/she means that having that mistake in purpose proves that ningning sings live and not with the use of autotune.
The fact that Aespa can blame the black mamba everytime something is wrong with their performance lol.. so cute
@@back2u842 that an insult or...?
카리나 윈터로 인해 에스파 입덕하지만 진짜 귀요미는 닝닝임..ㅋㅋ
그리고 최종 종착역은 지젤..⭐
ㄹㅇ카리나 윈터로 입덕하고 지젤 닝닝이 출구 닫음
지젤은 좀 쉴드불가라;;
@@Vbnm0112 뭘 쉴드친다는 거지?🤷🏻♂️🤷🏻♂️
@@Vbnm0112 옜날 데뷔초 논란 말씀하시는거
같은데 그거 전부 다 루머입니다
음정 진짜 하나도 안 흔들린다... 어떻게 저렇게 깔끔하게부름 ㅠ
가수라는 이름 달고 활동하려면 저정도는 해야하는게 당연한데 참;; 언제부턴가 가수가 아니라 그냥 엔터테이너같은 사람만 나오니 안타깝네
@@감나무-j9m 갑자기 먼소리지
@@감나무-j9m 가수도 본인만의 음역대가 있을 거 아니에요.. 고음 잘하면 노래 잘하는 게 아니라 그 음역대에서 잘 부르는 게 잘 부르는 거예요 ㅋㅋ 물론 고음을 잘할 수록 노래 분위기도 살고 노래에 더 유리하겠지만 고음 잘한다고 노래 잘하는 건 아님ㅇㅇ 닝닝이 부른 마리아는 웬만한 가수들도 못부르는데 저 정도면 개 잘하는 거지.. 심지어 데뷔 1년도 안 됐고 예능 초보인 거 고려해 보면 진짜 ㅎㄷㄷ한 거임
@@user-pi4os7rr8v 데뷔1년도 안됐다는건 이유가될수없음 애초에 실력적으로 모자람이 없을 때 가수로 데뷔하고 활동하는 게 맞지않아요? 그리고 저 영상만 봐도 음정 흔들리는거 그냥 눈에 보이는데
@@감나무-j9m 예능 초보고 저 곡이 마냥 쉬운 건 아니잖아.. 음정 흔들려도 저 정도면 잘 부르는데 억지로 트집 좀 잡지 마셈ㅋㅋㄱ 데뷔 1년도 안 되면 저런 예능 경험이 거의 없기에 긴장 엄청했을 거임 ;; 아~ 그리고 너 첫번 째 다답글 보니까 닝닝은 가수니까 저 정도하는 게 당연하다했더라? 그럼 못부르는 건 아니란 건데 나한텐 음정 겁나 흔들린다고 싸잡아대넹ㅋㅋㅋ
Best part of ningning vocals.. she IS TOO GOOD at lower register.. which is not for everyone....her HIGHnotes no doubt!!!! She is best of the best
2:50 와 진짜 잘 부른다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ음정 하나 안떨리고 쫙 올라가네
뒤에 지젤 귀여워요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ마리아앜ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅇㅈ..
ㅇㅈ..
와 성공했을 때 소름 돋았다 진짜 와 목소리가 어케 저러지 진짜 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
The crack was funny but the finale is just wow. That was so clean asf. Ningning 4th Gen Main Vocalist y'all.
It was really funny. I guess she was too nervous. I’m sure she can hit that cleanly if she was less nervous. Also, I love how she changed her tactic to hit that hight note. Effortless and so clean.
@@omega5790 if u watch it in eng sub you will see that it was on script :))
Actually it was scripted, ningning did the crack on purpose that's how they play the game and also knowing bros always prepared everything in order for a show
Lol , I knew it🤣
@@inri7987 but there's no eng sub yet??
닝닝 고음 성공 후 멤버들 기뻐 뛰는거 귀엽네ㅜㅋㅋ
역시SM...완벽한 바다 창법......ㅋㅋㅋ
she's holding back herself and she haven't shown her fullest potential bc she wants us to anticipate more in the future. this is just a teaser of what she can do more. we all know sm main vocalists never fails us to give the best among the best. and ningning is just 18?!?! she can show us more in the future, just wait.
omgg idk but she prolly reminds me of taeyeon and bada,, they were both like 17/18 when they debuted uwuuu
Yesss... So agree
Agreed
@@mawiya7010 more lika bada since her tone sounds kinda like bada at least to me
@@sally-dg3ml i mean yes, she sounds like bada. but i'm referring on the debut age of these main vocalists--taeyeon, bada and ningning
this song is really hard to sing but she did a great job shes only 18 but look at her voice
She's so cool
@@didi6697 yess absolutely
She's indeed born-to-be where she is now
mainvocal
@@helentrinidadgabata8959 yes bestiana yes
Vocal queen of 4th generation ♥️♥️